People & Craft · 2 November 2026 · 3 min read

The band room off Shandon Street

Written for my hospitality blog, ciaran-murray.com, on 2 November 2026. Kept as written: the links are updated and the sign-up lines are gone.

My mother bought me two things the year I turned fourteen. A keyboard, and a music theory book.

What I can tell you is where the two of us ended up: a band room off Shandon Street, side by side, learning to read music at the same time, in a room full of people who already could.

The band was the Buttera — the Cork Butter Exchange Brass and Reed Band, so called because the Butter Market put its name to them as sponsors in 1878. They reckon they go back further than that, to a St Mary’s Band playing in the 1840s, but they’re honest that the trail goes cold: no records survive from the 1800s, and they say themselves that the early history is clouded. What hasn’t changed is that they teach for nothing. Rehearsals on a Wednesday night, lessons at noon on a Saturday, for anyone in the city who wants them.

I didn’t know any of that at fourteen. I knew the room smelled of valve oil, and that nobody cared who your father was.

What a band room teaches you that a lesson doesn’t

A teacher will tell you your timing is out. A band tells you by moving away from you.

That’s the whole education, and it takes about two weeks. You play your own part while hearing thirty others. You come in on a beat you cannot see, on faith, because the count has been running in your head since the last bar you played. And you learn the thing nobody writes down: you can hear a wrong entry long before you can hear a wrong note. A player who comes in half a beat early is more obvious, and does more damage, than one who plays the wrong note altogether.

The conductor doesn’t make a sound all night. All they do is hold the time.

The pass is a band room

I’ve spent more than a decade on the other side of a bar, and the best description I have of a good Saturday night is that it has a tempo.

You can feel it from the pass. Three chefs working, a full book, the floor moving around behind you — and underneath all of it there’s a count. Dockets coming in at a rate. Plates going out at a rate. A table being cleared while the next one’s drinks are being made. When the tempo is right, nobody is rushing and nothing is waiting, and a guest who has never worked a day in hospitality will tell you afterwards that the service was lovely without being able to say why.

And when it drops, you hear it before you see it. Not a disaster — a hesitation. A docket sits thirty seconds longer than it should. One chef looks up. That’s the half-beat early entry, and if nobody names it in the next minute you’ll be forty minutes down by nine o’clock and the room will feel frantic at exactly the same covers it felt calm at last week.

So name it. Out loud, early, while it’s still small. “We’re drifting — let’s get three out together.” That’s the whole job. You’re not cooking and you’re not carrying plates. You’re holding the time.

What it’s worth

For anyone in their first season: start listening for the tempo on your next shift. You won’t be able to change it yet, but you’ll start to hear when it goes, and hearing it is the whole skill. Everything else is learnable.

For anyone running a room: the difference between a service that feels calm and one that feels frantic is almost never the number of covers, and it’s usually not the number of staff. It’s whether someone is holding the count, and whether they say so when it slips.

And for anyone paying the wages: a room with the tempo right turns tables faster, sells more at the end of the night, and loses fewer people in February. It costs nothing. It just has to be somebody’s actual job rather than something that happens by luck.

My mother and I were both terrible for about a year. She stuck at it longer than I did that first winter. Sixteen years later I’m still counting — standing at a pass on a Saturday night, in a white shirt rather than a band uniform, doing the same thing I learned in a room off Shandon Street.

Sin é mo scéal.

All essays · Editorial standards

Get in touch

Tell me the day, the place and what you need, and I will tell you straight away whether I am free. It costs nothing to ask.

Send a messageThe song listor ring 089 606 7737